Changeset: 115178716
Split ways. Created residential ways, primary ways, and primary links. Aligned ways to imagery. #Kaart 2021
Closed by VigotheCarpathian
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (17919 en) |
---|---|
hashtags | #Kaart |
source | Maxar, Mapillary |
Discussion
-
Comment from 4004
hi, thanks for splitting the ways, even if I don't agree with this approach. but could you explain these strange links? eg https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1013850984 ? they are not there on the ground, and without turn restrictions at intersections they seem useless
-
Comment from 4004
oh, you've also removed turn:lane tags, without adding them on new ways, which is quite sad and I think we need to consider reversion of your changeset
-
Comment from VigotheCarpathian
Greetings 4004,
I have deleted the link roads at way 1013850985, way 1013850983, and way 1013850984 which i agree were created in error. Additionally, I updated the lanes: tag on way 615360834, and the lanes: and and turn:lanes: tags on way 630982940 according to Maxar imagery and my best understanding of the lanes: and turn:lanes: pages on the OSM wiki. Since this is a oneway, my read of the wiki is that this way should not have lanes:forward/lanes:backward or turn:lanes:forward tags, only lanes: and turn:lanes: tags.
Thanks for catching this. Please let me know if there are further edits you believe should be made in this area. -
Comment from 4004
Thanks for fixing these. I still think it would've been easier to revert and start anew, but if you want to keep it, please also check lanes and turn:lanes tagging on these ways:
Deleted tag turn:lanes (forward or backward):left|through|through;right
way 44013363
way 615360834
left|through|through|right
way 630982988
left|through|through|right
way 630982940
through|through;right
way 630982948
left|through|through
way 630982956
way 630982967
way 630982975
way 630982984You are correct in that forward/backward is needed only where the road mapped is two way
-
Comment from VigotheCarpathian
Hello again,
I've reviewed lanes: and turn:lane data on this section of vulica Voĺhi Solamavaj, paying particular attention to the ways you mentioned, and making frequent reference to Maxar imagery and Mapillary tracks in this area (including the tracks you uploaded in late 2019). Please let me know if I missed anything, or feel free to make any further edits you deem necessary. Thanks again for your time and attention. -
Comment from 4004
thank you for your time - I should've warned you that splitting such a long road like this one into two would be a lot of effort, especially when turn lanes are involved (hence why the local community left them as was). no physical separation meant it wasn't required to split it
- 1013850983, v1
- 1013850984, v1
- 1013850985, v1
- 1013850986, v1
- 1013850987, v1
- улица Лизы Чайкиной (1013850988), v1
- 3-й переулок Ольги Соломовой (29156019), v10
- улица Лизы Чайкиной (29163828), v16
- улица Лизы Чайкиной (29163829), v12
- переулок Фолюш (29163851), v12
- 29163884, v12
- 29163911, v11
- улица Ольги Соломовой (33736438), v18
- улица Ольги Соломовой (44013363), v26
- улица Советских Пограничников (67027244), v14
- улица Лизы Чайкиной (87322338), v11
- улица Лизы Чайкиной (87322358), v10
- 128081238, v10
- 128081243, v7
- Тенистый переулок (173109852), v9
Relations (15)
- улица Лизы Чайкиной (1308311), v19
- Автобус № 3: Железнодорожный вокзал — Фолюш (2882962), v24
- Маршрутное такси № 10: Девятовка–5 — Фолюш (2901535), v44
- Маршрутное такси № 35: Облпсихдиспансер — Фолюш (2904175), v38
- Троллейбус № 10: Девятовка — Фолюш (2904293), v23
- Троллейбус № 1: Азот — Фолюш (2904295), v32
- Троллейбус № 4: Азот — Фолюш (2908395), v28
- Автобус № 36: Вишневец — Фолюш (2916015), v29
- Автобус № 23: СП «Теста» — Фолюш (2916092), v39
- Троллейбус № 13: Молодёжная улица — Фолюш (2924883), v21
- Троллейбус № 15: Молодёжная улица — Фолюш (2924925), v29
- Маршрутное такси № 11: рынок "Южный" — Фолюш (2930843), v27
- Маршрутное такси № 3: Железнодорожный вокзал — Фолюш (2930947), v19
- Автобус № 27: Белвторполимер — Фолюш (2998239), v40
8514381, v2
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |