Changeset: 126311174
Name:etymology:wikidata (https://mapcomplete.osm.be/etymology.html)
Closed by deleted
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18463 ru) |
---|---|
source | knowledge |
Discussion
- Comment from ruugie
-
Comment from user_389895
Yes, I am aware of this.
All my mass edits are not touching any existing tags, just adding new tags (Name:etymology:wikidata) to streets in Russia. Something that is near impossible to do one by one (given hundreds and thousands of them).
I share some of your concerns about local awareness, so I do add only most generic and common in Russia etymology definitions, leaving most of the others to local experts.
My regrets if this makes you worry; I hope there should be some validators that could show these edits as non-harmful (as they are not changing things,just adding).
Thank you for caring about OSM quality! :) -
Comment from user_389895
P.S. Before doing this I've spent several days mapping manually thousands of streets in my home city (Ulyanovsk) and several other Russian cities and villages to became accustomed with common and edge cases and see what could be done to cover the whole country (well, actually just for my liking of etymology :))
I am aware, that ordinary 'wikidata' tag is never to be bulk-edited, as every street may have it's unique history. But 'name:etimology:wikidata' is different in a way, that it specify generics semantic for the name of many streets (Q7777019 Meadow for all the "Meadow street"s in this case), so I see mass edit as a necessity rather than danger in such cases.
After all, I don't expect these my edits to cause any conflicts, as street names etimology in Russia was pretty nonexistent in OSM before this.
To be on a safe side I always use geocodeArea:"Russia" to limit the area and strict equality checks (not regexes) for street names, to be sure not to touch anything unplanned.
I also care! :) -
Comment from SomeoneElse
> Yes, I am aware of this.
OK, please link to where you had the discussion with the local community.
- Луговая улица (279299288), v2
- Луговая улица (279570034), v4
- Луговая улица (279751299), v5
- Луговая улица (279818412), v2
- Луговая улица (279846884), v5
- Луговая улица (280448830), v4
- Луговая улица (280658236), v5
- Луговая улица (280956644), v3
- Луговая улица (280995501), v6
- Луговая улица (281000447), v9
- Луговая улица (281247600), v6
- Луговая улица (281257131), v3
- Луговая улица (281266151), v4
- Луговая улица (281294524), v4
- Луговая улица (281294529), v5
- Луговая улица (281395140), v3
- Луговая улица (281481142), v4
- Луговая улица (281481745), v3
- Луговая улица (281481746), v3
- Луговая улица (281507608), v3
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |