Changeset: 140641952
roads
Closed by HolloWorld
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18822 en) |
---|
Discussion
-
Comment from Kovoschiz
Please don't add the estate name to the `building=` . This is not the common practice, and makes the data more complicated.
-
Comment from HolloWorld
From wiki "...the primary name would be the most obvious name of the feature, the one that end users expect data consumers to expose in a label or other interface element."
As to me saw few hundred building only tagging as "block 1" and the navigation app do not add the estate name to the building, I'm quite f***ed up at the end
also on mapnik it do not show both estate name and building name at same time, searching more for just because the name is separated is costing me and others life.
-
Comment from Kovoschiz
1. That isn't relevant here. If you follow by the books, you would look at `addr:housename=` . Besides, another rule is not to artificially make composite names, ie combining different features' names.
2. It's the best option. All this does is make managing building names more complicated.
3. Not a data problem. Carto is a static raster map background. Any proper application should have more overlays and clickable buttons. -
Comment from Kovoschiz
There are many address formats which applications may not support. Even for UK. And HK is more complicated than UK in some sense.
-
Comment from Kovoschiz
1. Any GIS or geo-database application could do a spatial join to append the `landuse=residential` `name=` to `building=`. On the contrary, you can't remove them as easily when considering button and label names, which creates clutter. Bus routes has the same problem.
- 1203968427, v1
- 豐樂新邨B座 Merry Garden Block B (1203968428), v1
- 豐樂新邨A座 Merry Garden Block A (1203968429), v1
- 1203968430, v1
- 1203968431, v1
- 1203968432, v1
- 1203968433, v1
- 馬頭圍道 Ma Tau Wai Road (1203968434), v1
- 庇利街 Bailey Street (1203968435), v1
- 崇安街 Sung On Street (1203968436), v1
- 庇利街 Bailey Street (1203968437), v1
- 庇利街 Bailey Street (1203968438), v1
- 庇利街 Bailey Street (1203968439), v1
- 紅磡道 Hung Hom Road (1203968440), v1
- 大環道東 Tai Wan Road East (1203968441), v1
- 大環道東 Tai Wan Road East (1203968442), v1
- 紅磡道 Hung Hom Road (1203968443), v1
- 德康街 Tak Hong Street (1203968444), v1
- 德康街 Tak Hong Street (1203968445), v1
- 德康街 Tak Hong Street (1203968446), v1
- 九巴45線(九龍城碼頭→葵涌(麗瑤邨)) KMB 45 (Kowloon City Ferry → Kwai Chung (Lai Yiu Estate)) (15727841), v7
- 城巴機場快線A25(啟德→機場) Cityflyer A25 (Kai Tak → Airport) (15780835), v8
- 城巴機場快線A25(機場→啟德) Cityflyer A25 (Airport → Kai Tak) (15780836), v9
- 九巴11K線(竹園邨→紅磡站) KMB 11K (Chuk Yuen Estate → Hung Hom Station) (15818885), v4
- 九巴11X線(安泰(北)→紅磡站) KMB 11X (On Tai (North) → Hung Hom Station) (15822765), v3
- 九巴11X線(紅磡站→安泰(北)) KMB 11X (Hung Hom Station → On Tai (North)) (15822766), v4
- 九巴12A線(長沙灣(海達邨)→黃埔花園) KMB 12A (Cheung Sha Wan (Hoi Tat Estate) → Whampoa Garden) (15912658), v10
- 九巴12A線(黃埔花園→長沙灣(海達邨)) KMB 12A (Whampoa Garden → Cheung Sha Wan (Hoi Tat Estate)) (15912659), v5
- 九巴15線(平田 → 紅磡(紅鸞道)) KMB 15 (Ping Tin → Hung Hom (Hung Luen Road)) (16125901), v10
- 九巴15X線(藍田(廣田邨)→紅磡站) KMB 15X (Lam Tin (Kwong Tin Estate) → Hung Hom Station) (16158238), v2
- 九巴21線(彩雲→紅磡站) KMB 21 (Choi Wan → Hung Hom Station) (16205748), v2
- 九巴28線(樂華→尖沙咀碼頭) KMB 28 (Lok Wah → Star Ferry) (16246911), v3
- 11159271000, v1
- 11159271001, v1
- 11159271002, v1
- 11159271003, v1
- 11159271004, v1
- 11159278705, v1
- 11159278706, v1
- 11159278707, v1
- 11159278708, v1
- 11159278709, v1
- 11159278710, v1
- 11159278711, v1
- 11159278712, v1
- 11159278713, v1
- 11159278714, v1
- 11159278715, v1
- 11159278716, v1
- 11159278717, v1
- 11159278718, v1
- 11159278719, v1
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |