Changeset: 29150977
Erie PA cont'd
Closed by Your Village Maps
Tags
build | 2.3-650-gad99430 |
---|---|
created_by | Potlatch 2 |
version | 2.3 |
Discussion
-
Comment from rickmastfan67
I'm curious, but why did you in this changeset (and others) change how the ref tag for PA 5 Alternate was tagged? In 99.9% of PA, we do it as 'PA # Alternate', not 'ALT PA #'.
-
Comment from Your Village Maps
Because it wasn't rendered using the standard OSM rendering; it only showed up with the MapQuest Open renderer.
-
Comment from Your Village Maps
By the way, I just tried to switch to view using MQO and it was blank (light grey). Cycle, Transport, and Humanitarian show up, but not MQO. Weird. I did check a number of times after I made the edits to make sure the PA highway shields for the Alternate PA 5 stayed the same, and they did.
-
Comment from rickmastfan67
Still, wouldn't changing the tagging for the OSM rendering (Mapnik) be considered 'tagging for the renderer'? There are other apps like routers that rely on the data in the 'ref' tag. Some of them might not understand the abbreviation and when speaking it, confuse the driver. That's why in almost every state we don't abbreviate these tags.
-
Comment from rickmastfan67
Even for 'business' highways in PA, we don't abbreviate the text as 'bus' (just so Mapnik renders it), but spell it out fully.
-
Comment from rickmastfan67
Maybe submit a ticket over @ https://github.com/gravitystorm/openstreetmap-carto for them to bump up the number of rendered characters by 3 or 4. I know 'ref=US 19 Truck" renders just fine, and that's 3 less characters then "ref=PA 5 Alternate".
- 330619584, v1
- 330619585, v1
- 330619586, v1
- 330619587, v1
- Chautauqua Boulevard (11888660), v5
- GE Access Road (11899461), v4
- GE Access Road (11899463), v4
- East Lake Road (63047307), v7
- East Lake Road (63047308), v11
- East Lake Road (63048379), v10
- East Lake Road (63048382), v9
- East Lake Road (63047307), v8
- East Lake Road (63047308), v12
- Franklin Avenue (63047312), v6
- 330624651, v1
- 330624652, v1
- 330624653, v1
- Bayfront Bikeway (330624654), v1
- 330624655, v1
- 330624656, v1
- 3376122310, v1
- 3376122311, v1
- 3376122312, v1
- 3376122313, v1
- Ricardo's (3376122314), v1
- 3376122315, v1
- 3376122316, v1
- 3376122317, v1
- 3376122318, v1
- 3376122319, v1
- 3376122320, v1
- 3376122321, v1
- 3376122322, v1
- 3376122323, v1
- 3376122324, v1
- 3376122325, v1
- 3376122326, v1
- 3376122327, v1
- 3376122328, v1
- 3376122329, v1
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |