Changeset: 72454958
R3: updates and corrections
Closed by StijnRR
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (15238 nl) |
---|---|
source | SPW 2018 aerial imagery |
Discussion
-
Comment from juminet
Hi StijnRR,
I noticed that you supress the landuse=residential of Charleroi. Is there a good reason for that? BTW it is true that this zone should be split in several smaller polygons...
Happy mapping,
juminet -
Comment from StijnRR
For several reasons. 1. It overlapped many existing residential and other landuses. 2. In the good old days such big polygons were acceptable but now it is much better work more detailed. It takes longer before the map gets some colour. But that the map looks better, doesn't mean that it (or the database) is better. 3. Such a big polygon is bound to become a cluttered multipolygon. I once spent many evenings cleaning, repairing and simplifying a forest which had become a multipolygon with many outers and inners, and had many polygons in it which were not part of the multipolygon. There are still plenty of such examples left.
So I don't believe it would work out well starting from such a big polygon. Not everyone works meticulously enough for that (and this polygon is a proof thereof). -
Comment from juminet
You're right. I'm also splitting large MP of forests (especially for specifying the leaf_type and leaf_cycle) into smaller polygons. Hopefully someone will take care of the landuse in Charleroi, but it is a lot of work...
Cheers.
- Rue de Bomerée (705921112), v1
- Rue de Bomerée (705921113), v1
- Rue de Bomerée (705921114), v1
- Rue de Bomerée (705921115), v1
- Rue de Bomerée (705921116), v1
- Rue de Bomerée (705921117), v1
- Rue de Bomerée (705921118), v1
- Rue de Bomerée (705921119), v1
- 705921120, v1
- 705921121, v1
- 705921122, v1
- 705921123, v1
- 705921124, v1
- 705921125, v1
- 705921126, v1
- 705921127, v1
- 705921128, v1
- Rue de Bomerée (705921129), v1
- Rue de Bomerée (705921130), v1
- Rue de Bomerée (705921131), v1
Relations (1-20 of 24)
- 1
- 2
- R3 (255411), v39
- TEC 109a Chimay Gare - Charleroi Sud (9086774), v13
- TEC 109a Chimay Gare - Charleroi Sud (9086776), v15
- TEC 109a Chimay Gare - Charleroi Sud (9090859), v12
- TEC 109a Chimay Gare - Charleroi Sud (9103518), v9
- TEC 109a Beaumont Athénée - Charleroi Sud (9103531), v5
- TEC 109a Chimay Gare - Charleroi Sud (9103554), v11
- TEC 109a Chimay Gare - Charleroi Sud (9110474), v8
- TEC 109a Chimay Gare - Charleroi Sud (9110495), v9
- TEC 109a Chimay Gare - Charleroi Sud (9110500), v9
- TEC 109a Chimay Gare - Charleroi Sud (9110543), v10
- TEC 109a Sivry Gare - Charleroi Sud (9110567), v9
- TEC 109a Chimay Gare - Charleroi Sud (9110657), v6
- TEC 109a Chimay Gare - Charleroi Sud (9110706), v7
- TEC 109a Charleroi Sud - Chimay Gare (9112621), v7
- TEC 109a Charleroi Sud - Chimay Gare (9113553), v7
- TEC 109a Charleroi Sud - Chimay Gare (9113559), v7
- TEC 109a Charleroi Sud - Chimay Gare (9113605), v7
- TEC 109a Charleroi Sud - Chimay Gare (9118681), v6
- TEC 109a Charleroi Sud - Chimay Gare (9118683), v8
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |