Changeset: 95718255
fix motorways around Airport area
Closed by 小智智
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (17329 Debian en) |
---|
Discussion
-
Comment from Kovoschiz
1. Please notice that `=motorway_link` is used as a compromise on non-Expressway roads leading to Expressway. `motorway=` is used to aid in this representation.
2. Please check usage on `=carriageway` and `access_control=` -
Comment from 小智智
1. The long-standing agreement is that highway=motorway is used "strictly in the legal sense", and highway=motorway_link has motorway restrictions. The wiki page clearly specifies that the link starts where the regulation commences and ends
"Besides its use for on/off ramps, motorway_link is also used for the slip roads/ramps into and out of motorway service areas/rest areas. In this case the motorway_link should go from the motorway towards the services as far as motorway regulations (for example no pedestrians) apply. In the UK, this is indicated by a sign. Similarly the exit road from the services should be a motorway_link from the point where motorway regulations commence.
"2. carriageway=* is not documented anywhere and has no meaning here. access_control=* also the same.
-
Comment from Kovoschiz
1. Have you even tried to understand the "point" means the point of diverge? You get complaints for not following `_link` continuity
2. This is about usage. I'm merely picking this up for now, not proposing it yet. Do you have any good solutions? -
Comment from 🗺🗺🗺
"Use highway=motorway_link for link roads (sliproads / ramps) leading to and from a highway=motorway."
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/95718255
- 順匯路 Shun Wui Road (884063616), v1
- 機場路 Airport Road (884063617), v1
- 暢連路 Cheong Lin Road (23399341), v14
- 23399342, v13
- 暢連路 Cheong Lin Road (23399348), v14
- 航天城交匯處 Sky City Interchange (23399370), v8
- 暢連路 Cheong Lin Road (23399374), v11
- 東岸路 East Coast Road (23399463), v26
- 機場路 Airport Road (23399501), v28
- 北大嶼山公路 North Lantau Highway (26561042), v34
- 機場路 Airport Road (26561043), v30
- 北大嶼山公路 North Lantau Highway (26561047), v39
- 北大嶼山公路 North Lantau Highway (26561048), v36
- 暢連路 Cheong Lin Road (28069488), v10
- 東岸路 East Coast Road (30783218), v13
- 東岸路 East Coast Road (30783232), v13
- 東岸路 East Coast Road (30783234), v16
- 東岸路 East Coast Road (30783236), v13
- 東岸路 East Coast Road (30783322), v17
- 30783344, v13
Relations (1-20 of 29)
- 1
- 2
- A41 (Sha Tin (Yu Chui Court) - Airport) (1294536), v92
- 城巴機場快線A12線 Cityflyer A12 (小西灣(藍灣半島) Siu Sai Wan (Island Resort) → 機場 Airport) (3548874), v112
- 龍運巴士A33X線 Long Win Bus A33X (機場 Airport → 屯門(富泰) Tuen Mun (Fu Tai)) (6504285), v59
- 龍運巴士A36線 Long Win Bus A36 (機場 Airport → 朗屏站 Long Ping Station) (6504369), v56
- 龍運巴士A36線 Long Win Bus A36 (機場 Airport → 朗屏站 Long Ping Station (經國泰城 via Cathay City)) (6504384), v55
- 龍運巴士A36線 Long Win Bus A36 (朗屏站 Long Ping Station → 機場 Airport) (6504470), v57
- 龍運巴士A37線 Long Win Bus A37 (洪水橋 Hung Shui Kiu → 機場 Airport) (6504599), v62
- 龍運巴士A47X線 Long Win Bus A47X (大埔(富亨) Tai Po (Fu Heng) → 機場 Airport (特快 Express)) (6505883), v70
- 龍運巴士A33X線 Long Win Bus A33X (機場 Airport → 屯門(富泰) Tuen Mun (Fu Tai) (經國泰城 via Cathay City)) (6529246), v56
- 龍運巴士A33X線 Long Win Bus A33X (屯門(富泰) Tuen Mun (Fu Tai) → 機場 Airport) (6529247), v69
- 龍運巴士A33線 Long Win Bus A33 (屯門(悅湖山莊) Tuen Mun (Yuet Wu Villa) → 機場 Airport) (6531409), v60
- 龍運巴士NA33線 Long Win Bus NA33 (大橋香港口岸 HZMB HK Port → 屯門(富泰) Tuen Mun (Fu Tai)) (6706899), v64
- 龍運巴士A47X線 Long Win Bus A47X (大埔(富亨) Tai Po (Fu Heng) → 機場 Airport (特快 Express) (經大埔中心 via Tai Po Central)) (6925148), v51
- 龍運巴士N30S線 Long Win Bus N30S (元朗(東) Yuen Long (East) → 東涌站 Tung Chung Station) (7184504), v78
- 龍運巴士N30P線 Long Win Bus N30P (紅橋 Hung Kiu → 東涌站 Tung Chung Station) (7184505), v49
- 龍運巴士N30線 Long Win Bus N30 (元朗(東) Yuen Long (East) → 東涌站 Tung Chung Station) (7184506), v76
- 城巴B5線 Citybus B5 (大橋香港口岸 HZMB HK Port → 欣澳站 Sunny Bay Station) (8833965), v18
- 城巴B5線 Citybus B5 (大橋香港口岸 HZMB HK Port → 欣澳站 Sunny Bay Station (經迪士尼樂園 via Disneyland)) (8833971), v21
- 嶼巴B4線 New Lantao Bus B4 (大橋香港口岸 HZMB Hong Kong Port ↺ 機場(客運大樓) Airport (Passenger Terminal)) (8856206), v31
- 嶼巴B6線 New Lantao Bus B6 (大橋香港口岸 HZMB HK Port → 滿東邨 Mun Tung Estate) (8857663), v21
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |