Changeset: 96491928
Land mine areas and warnings
Closed by Girolamo
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (17329 de) |
---|---|
source | DGU ortofoto |
Discussion
-
Comment from aceman444
Hi, I said the names are invalid and shouldn't be there. hazard=minefield is enough.
Also, what source is 'DGU ortofoto'? On which ortofoto imagery can you see mines hidden in the ground? Please provide your real source, thanks. -
Comment from Girolamo
Hey! I edited the comments that have been placed there by an expert of the demining service. Please see the comments on OSM improvments - and additionally I have been using the DGU orthophoto. If you do not know: this is the official aerial image of Croatia by the Croatian geodetic service (DGU=Državna geodetska uprava) that is allowed to be used as OSM imagery. The markings are very relevant as one can see these days. It has to be well visible.
-
Comment from aceman444
Ok, I can see dgu.hr imagery in the JOSM editor, which you also use. But I see no mines in the aerial imagery, as of course the mines are underground. So that wasn't the real source for the data. You say some demining expert put some OSM notes on the map. I wonder how precise he could describe the mine area polygons. But OK, so just please next time quote the real data source, thanks.
In OSM it is not allowed to make things "well visible" by putting random personal remarks into the name tag. You have to tag objects properly so that all consumers (people and applications) can properly understand what they are. Then they will be well visible.
It seems the 'hazard' tag was recently voted upon:
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:hazard
It may be needed to add the boundary=hazard tags to the areas you have created and probably to remove the 'military' tags unless the military still actively uses the areas. Thanks.
Ways (1-20 of 25)
- 1
- 2
- Danger! Land mine area! (888946811), v1
- Danger! Land mine area! (888946812), v1
- Danger! Land mine area! (888946813), v1
- Danger! Land mine area! (888946814), v1
- Danger! Land mine area! (888946815), v1
- Danger! Land mine area! (888946816), v1
- Danger! Land mine area! (888946817), v1
- Danger! Land mine area! (888946818), v1
- 888946819, v1
- Danger! Land mine area! (888946820), v1
- Danger! Land mine area! (888946821), v1
- Danger! Land mine area! (888946822), v1
- Danger! Land mine area! (888946823), v1
- Danger! Land mine area! (888946824), v1
- Danger! Land mine area! (888946825), v1
- 888946826, v1
- Danger! Land mine area! (888946827), v1
- Danger! Land mine area! (888946828), v1
- Danger! Land mine area! (888946829), v1
- 50212755, v20
- Danger! Land mine area! (8264513621), v1
- 8264513622, v1
- 8264513623, v1
- 8264513624, v1
- 8264513625, v1
- 8264513626, v1
- 8264513627, v1
- 8264513628, v1
- 8264513629, v1
- 8264513630, v1
- 8264513631, v1
- 8264513632, v1
- 8264513633, v1
- 8264513634, v1
- 8264513635, v1
- 8264513636, v1
- 8264513637, v1
- 8264513638, v1
- 8264513639, v1
- 8264513640, v1
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |