Changeset: 127571223
Naturpark Rieserferner-Ahrn Ersterfassung
Closed by luschi
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18570 de) |
---|---|
source | South Tyrol Orthofoto 2020; geoservices.buergernetz.bz.it: Naturparke |
Discussion
-
Comment from SekeRob
Hi,
I don't speak German and you don't speak italian I'm sure given the CS comment, BUT, your 'erstserfassung' of the 'Alpine watershed" https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/14461262 is flagged by OSM Inspector with an unclosed boundary alert. Do you have any plans to continue the capture of this watershed area of this now 2 months old entry?
ciao
-
Comment from luschi
Hi,
I do not changed anything at the "Alpin watershed"!
In this changeset I added the relation for the "Parco Naturale Vedrette di Ries-Aurina" and because of cutting the borders from Italy, the relation(Alpine ...) was also cut.
As you can see in the history from that relation I dont changed any thing in the tagging. After my "Ersterfassung" was only added 2 additional ways to this relation because of cutting existing ways.Maybe this watershed should not be mapped as a boundary, but for this I am the wrong person to discuss with....
Maybe the user what initially added this to OSM can help you...regards
-
Comment from SekeRob
Sorry about that.... I go by the rule of "change it, own it". On your suggestion, looked in Turbo overpass and found a wiki link describing type=watershed, 2500 uses. most in France, few in the Americas, none in the Alpine region,
Utilisation does not require a closed loop albeit, the function is truly to capture the different flows that combine into the water collection that goes out the waterway into a lake, sea or ocean.
I have my doubt of the correct use here, it seems to infer a large area outline from where all water runs down eventually into the Med/Adriatic, No actual waterways have been tagged, in fact it would be a monster job to do that.
I see what the originator intended.Anyway, I've change the type, now I own it and see what nukes will come down.
ciao
Ways (12)
- 1104070925, v1
- 1104070926, v1
- Italia - Österreich (1104070927), v1
- Italia - Österreich (1104070928), v1
- 1104070929, v1
- 1104070930, v1
- 1104070931, v1
- 49129299, v7
- 49167561, v28
- Italia - Österreich (962060482), v3
- Italia - Österreich (962262157), v2
- 1097515448, v4
Relations (18)
- Naturpark Rieserferner-Ahrn - Parco Naturale Vedrette di Ries-Aurina (14698221), v1
- Österreich (16239), v1179
- Trentino-Alto Adige/Südtirol (45757), v204
- Bolzano - Bozen (47046), v138
- Rasen-Antholz - Rasun-Anterselva (47320), v14
- Prettau - Predoi (47339), v20
- Tirol (52343), v320
- Bezirk Schwaz (80051), v98
- Gemeinde Brandberg (80103), v26
- Italia (365331), v476
- Bezirk Lienz (539866), v62
- Gemeinde Sankt Jakob in Defereggen (1019097), v23
- Penisola italiana (4056532), v466
- Pustertal - Val Pusteria (6537725), v14
- 6721737, v6
- 7873095, v5
- 8704506, v9
- Alpine watershed (14461262), v11
- 10103172892, v1
- 10103172893, v1
- 10103172894, v1
- 10103172895, v1
- 10103172896, v1
- 10103172897, v1
- 10103172898, v1
- 10103172899, v1
- 10103172900, v1
- 10103172901, v1
- 10103172902, v1
- 10103172903, v1
- 10103172904, v1
- 10103172905, v1
- 10103172906, v1
- 10103172907, v1
- 10103172908, v1
- 10103172909, v1
- 10103172910, v1
- 10103172911, v1
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |