Changeset: 139483739
Remove bicycle=yes from highway=residential in Connecticut. Highway=residential implies bicycle=yes, as documented in the sources below.
Closed by jnighan
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (18622 en) |
---|
Discussion
- Comment from jnighan
- Comment from jnighan
- Comment from jnighan
-
Comment from andrewsuzuki
There were valid cases where bicycle=yes was being used to override access=no/private/etc, for example way 765837446. Technically it could also override vehicle=* but I didn't find any cases. https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:access#Land-based_transportation
-
Comment from jnighan
Is that not a conflict? It is my understanding that access=no (etc.) implies bicycle=no, so access=no and bicycle=yes seems self-contradictory. The wiki page for access=* says, "If only specific transport modes are forbidden, for example, at a vehicle no-entry sign, use a more specific restriction like vehicle=no or motor_vehicle=no over the general key access."
-
Comment from jnighan
If I'm wrong, I'm happy to revert my changeset.
-
Comment from andrewsuzuki
There should definitely be more page on the wiki on this. But on the Key:access page, it says under List of possible values for access=no: "No access for the general public. Consider using additional access (like foot=yes or bicycle=permissive, etc.) to indicate who can use the element."
And under Transport mode restrictions it gives the example of access=no + bus=yes, among others.
Also from the dedicated access=no page: "access=no, as any other access=* value may be overridden by more specific access tags. See access=* to see in detail how access restrictions are defined. E.g. a road tagged access=no and psv=yes generally withdraws any legal right of way but permits public service vehicles."
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:access%3Dno
Probably don't have to revert the whole changeset, can just find the specific cases with overpass...I can do that if you want
- Ocean Drive West (9287349), v24
- Wilson Avenue (10163444), v7
- Sherman Street (10163759), v11
- Harding Road (10165919), v12
- Eunice Avenue (10166946), v6
- Old Orchard Park (10167040), v7
- Rowland Road (10167244), v11
- Dwight Street (10167500), v7
- Sullivan Place (10167673), v8
- Millard Street (10167976), v7
- Patton Place (10168464), v8
- Eastlawn Street (10168513), v6
- Charles Street (10168661), v6
- Riverside Drive (10168723), v13
- Ann Street (10169302), v5
- Catherine Terrace (10169351), v8
- Fern Street (10170288), v12
- Hurd Avenue (10170749), v8
- Old Field Drive (10170881), v7
- Gould Avenue (10171107), v6
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |