Changeset: 43780386
Revert mass addition of wikidata tags because of lack of prior discussion and unclear legal situation, see https://forum.openstreetmap.org/viewtopic.php?pid=618618
Closed by woodpeck_repair
Tags
bot | yes |
---|---|
created_by | osmtools/30252 (linux) |
Discussion
-
Comment from woodpeck_repair
This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 43771527, 43735782, 43687220, 43712790, 43740825, 43741976, 43739178, 43713951, 43734444, 43733780, 43708551, 43713727, 43713559, 43713276, 43636853, 43709600, 43687159, 43710431, 43638915, 43701420, 43766338, 43700668, 43765438, 43735945, 43641526, 43702976, 43638775, 43734355, 43713327, 43774677, 43709011, 43713585, 43713274, 43700753, 43765506, 43737831, 43734460, 43709209, 43734474, 43734622, 43659547, 43636731, 43708400, 43713839, 43738144, 43733662, 43686751, 43709914, 43770198, 43739537, 43741436, 43735543, 43673487, 43673412, 43713340, 43768926, 43735801, 43741366, 43700003, 43687168, 43713412, 43768752, 43735907, 43641586, 43768946, 43709381, 43734681, 43771956, 43771910, 43640411, 43708672, 43687181, 43713869, 43735731, 43714005, 43640288, 43687059, 43704888, 43699979, 43737914, 43740994, 43739848, 43739915, 43659828, 43713846, 43710425, 43671851, 43733642, 43766224, 43645291, 43732666, 43673258, 43686424, 43742029, 43733059, 43671179, 43659597, 43638978, 43699504, 43769623, 43771508, 43769596, 43709660, 43733845, 43738038, 43772667, 43708966, 43736615, 43659804, 43640130, 43646287, 43765390, 43736042, 43639140, 43771536, 43741281, 43765514, 43700077, 43636971, 43713554, 43742323, 43712735, 43639067, 43741541, 43673242, 43713767, 43638554, 43730961, 43772684, 43673223, 43639028, 43735877, 43713915, 43736807, 43672633, 43671070, 43640725, 43734649, 43734428, 43736795, 43713420, 43705025, 43772729, 43738075, 43641161, 43713943, 43659513, 43713962, 43765536, 43734366, 43713622, 43732570, 43700707, 43639014, 43713385, 43742152, 43774662, 43714086, 43686962, 43769927, 43714027, 43686603, 43735922, 43636660, 43714196, 43733858, 43673458, 43700883, 43765473, 43739130, 43771999, 43771898, 43736974, 43703161, 43713749, 43700849, 43713220, 43638667, 43741731, 43638563, 43713543, 43714162, 43737905, 43713829, 43703379, 43700639, 43741663, 43713479, 43704973, 43765491, 43699951, 43739993, 43638521, 43714114, 43713884, 43671642, 43738016, 43712954, 43709405, 43687021, 43713934, 43766239, 43687201, 43738067, 43735204, 43659744, 43700142, 43739102, 43673348, 43638492, 43645551, 43713312, 43673326, 43730949, 43713922, 43713613, 43737813, 43738178, 43687147, 43705941, 43734852, 43765464, 43714153, 43710074, 43699603, 43730963, 43739092, 43734336, 43713516, 43713966, 43713004, 43733955, 43736030, 43713816, 43713771, 43734842, 43768677, 43638610, 43671726, 43636775, 43732562, 43765520, 43699689, 43636836, 43713499, 43713289, 43709346, 43703541, 43673554, 43714131, 43639054, 43659631, 43673188, 43742426, 43702831, 43709803, 43733975, 43701033, 43742079, 43732648, 43686589, 43732633, 43709972, 43639118, 43640055, 43733874, 43645208, 43732751, 43713280, 43638631, 43741595, 43699476, 43713739, 43710134, 43730982, 43735866, 43710301, 43766334, 43687118, 43735832, 43739272, 43771372, 43733753, 43738160, 43640692, 43735951, 43640912, 43734327, 43713733, 43708757, 43736787, 43733761, 43659566, 43765382, 43640043, 43707106, 43713716, 43699439, 43739138, 43686651, 43735741, 43687177, 43771397, 43739356, 43771914, 43659849, 43708903, 43702160, 43734644, 43713597, 43772716, 43644892, 43709075, 43774668, 43738096, 43639098, 43644610, 43772689, 43640623, 43709860, 43774709, 43730495, 43770367, 43638707, 43644859, 43771550, 43714108, 43687092, 43734829, 43638984, 43737077, 43709258, 43709727, 43640892, 43741876, 43687192, 43739245, 43638577, 43772674, 43765454, 43710136, 43709170, 43638481, 43701207, 43765486, 43713296, 43686520, 43732554, 43699628, 43709980, 43714169, 43774648, 43638648, 43659858, 43687241, 43638507, 43736756, 43686721, 43659842, 43700044, 43734636, 43638530, 43734411, 43741710, 43771961, 43709282, 43645829, 43734543, 43737981, 43732969, 43730938, 43708820, 43702897, 43714039, 43768731, 43737898, 43710185, 43734396, 43641562, 43771922, 43645353, 43714058, 43709438, 43709307, 43738049, 43733681, 43671685, 43732741, 43733090, 43673520, 43638859, 43735790, 43714191, 43735775, 43771947, 43732921, 43686812, 43713731, 43713985, 43700106, 43738058, 43673287, 43638468, 43709505, 43765447, 43709326, 43671085, 43741142, 43733884, 43735914, 43640674, 43733965, 43710001, 43638691, 43730976, 43640077, 43765498, 43734705, 43699963, 43659845, 43638851, 43639002, 43742269, 43713040, 43686896, 43673372, 43766252, 43638516, 43713308, 43713019, 43735932, 43705133, 43765360, 43640304, 43671436, 43734387, 43766313, 43766217, 43765529, 43699921, 43732689, 43659584, 43702521, 43686708, 43735200, 43712828, 43686817, 43713797, 43699651, 43735218, 43737746, 43772181, 43659866, 43774719, 43686434, 43713549, 43709468, 43739109, 43704472, 43671017, 43671475, 43713428, 43659838, 43712893, 43638462, 43704928, 43659818.
-
Comment from DenisCarriere
Well if it's such a legal issue, why don't you revert every wikidata tag in the world?? Why single out these changsets, many of these changsets were done manually.
-
Comment from Teiron
what was an issue with this?
-
Comment from woodpeck
Teiron, major issue being that this was not sufficiently discussed before it was executed. You had a small number of pepole adding Wikidata entries all over the world, for places they had zero local knowledge about, aided by existing geo-information from Wikidata - which is fundamentally different to someone adding a Wikidata tag to a local thing they know about. It would have required prior reasonably public (i.e. not on a github ticket) discussion to establish if, how, and where to perform these edits, but discussion didn't happen.
Ways (15)
- Saskatoon John G. Diefenbaker International Airport (228733260), v7
- Regina International Airport (60076669), v8
- Shand Power Station (206130320), v3
- London International Airport (46225505), v16
- Centrale Laforge-2 (442136079), v3
- Fort McMurray International Airport (417403465), v3
- Abitibi Canyon Generating Station (255866638), v4
- 163632348, v3
- Greater Moncton International Airport (123685240), v17
- KIPLING GENERATING STATION (341075199), v3
- York Energy Centre (247885747), v4
- KIPLING GENERATING STATION (158944951), v6
- 260129413, v3
- Trenton Generating Station (211202482), v5
- Thunder Bay Generating Station (206131376), v5
Relations (1)
- Kästleinsmühle (462374481), v4
- Günthersbühl (33078280), v5
- Imboden (151780613), v4
- Raindorf (732094039), v3
- Bovina (151702458), v4
- Mörlheim (1635110955), v5
- Frisco City (153709108), v4
- Teller (150917999), v6
- Borgharen (3138267641), v3
- Mooringsport (151925503), v4
- Oosterhuizen (45502788), v7
- Dittigheim (59107530), v5
- Rudolphskirchen (3301807223), v4
- Perry Hall (2748915964), v3
- River Hebert (1628969774), v3
- Guisamopa (336177411), v4
- Walton (154349961), v5
- Bellefonte (151322195), v4
- Bastendorf (1614807043), v3
- Fruit Heights (150941565), v4
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |