Changeset: 61933415
bus routes
Closed by njtbusfan
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (14178 en) |
---|---|
source | bus schedules |
Discussion
-
Comment from nereocystis
Let's discuss these bus stops.
I am standardizing the bus stops from the official AC Transit GTFS data, using GO-Sync. This allows any future updates to be automatically applied.
The next step is to add each stop to the relationship bus routes. Unfortunately, that requires more software changes than I have made so far.
You made some recent changes which conflict with my changes.
Until then, I want to keep the bus stops standardized to the GTFS data, unless there are errors.
For example, you deleted the name for bus stop 51641. According to AC Transit, the name of the stop is Richmond BART. Here's an excerpt from the stop.txt
stop_id,stop_code,stop_name,stop_desc,stop_lat,stop_lon,zone_id,stop_url,location_type,parent_station9903840,51641,"Richmond BART",, 37.9358997,-122.3537587,,,0,
You have also changed the route_ref so that it refers to the complete bus route. This information is more appropriate for the relationship than for the route_ref.
See the examples here:
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:route_refLet's discuss this change.
Having many manual modifications makes future automated updates difficult. -
Comment from nereocystis
Also, you deleted DB from the Dumbarton Express. These lines are still listed under AC Transit GTFS.
Lines DB, DB1 are still official lines, according to:
https://dumbartonexpress.com/line-db-schedule/ -
Comment from nereocystis
I expect to revert this changeset soon. We can discuss making changes to the stops on a case by case basis.
Please, if you are changing the name of the stop, or route_ref, let's make sure that it is consistent with AC Transit GTFS info, unless that info is known to be incorrect.
- Mandela Parkway (619274143), v1
- 7th Street (619274144), v1
- 619274145, v1
- 619274146, v1
- 619274147, v1
- 619274148, v1
- 619274149, v1
- MacArthur Boulevard (619274150), v1
- 619274151, v1
- 619274152, v1
- 619274153, v1
- 619274154, v1
24208137, v552493651, v4120379365, v5120379387, v4202007383, v3202034992, v2202577491, v5- 6318691, v11
- AC Transit U (8588920), v1
- AC Transit 851 (to Fruitvale BART) (2717780), v53
- AC Transit 29 (to Christie Avenue & 64th Street) (2717935), v50
- AC Transit 62 (to Fruitvale BART) (2719463), v33
- AC Transit 62 (to West Oakland BART) (2719465), v30
- AC Transit 14 (to West Oakland BART) (2720857), v28
- AC Transit 14 (to Fruitvale BART) (2720858), v33
- AC Transit 217 (3259897), v37
- AC Transit 239 (3281722), v34
- AC Transit 251 (3295634), v44
- SamTrans ECR (northbound) (3441376), v192
- SamTrans ECR (southbound) (3441377), v185
- AC Transit NL (to San Francisco) (6062715), v17
- VTA 120 (7294252), v10
- VTA 181 (southbound) (7334256), v14
- VTA 181 (northbound) (7334258), v19
- AC Transit 29 (to Mandana Boulevard & Lakeshore Avenue) (8032900), v7
- AC Transit NL (to Eastmont Transit Center) (8037436), v12
- Line P to Palo Alto Transit Center (8367415), v16
- Line N (Counter-Clockwise) (8369838), v28
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |