Changeset: 75021616
Corriger Ligne orange pour PTv2
Closed by Alouette955
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (15031 fr) |
---|---|
source | OSM Inspector |
Discussion
-
Comment from azakh-world
Hi.
Don't you think that tag combination "public_transport=stop_position+railway=station" is somewhat confusing? Does such a node denote a station or a stop_position? From PTv2 and by the logic, stop_position (if mapped) should be separated from station.Best regards,
Alexey -
Comment from Alouette955
You are right .. .there was confusion when converting from PTv1 to PTv2 and it spread on all the network. The right tag is public_transport=stop_position. I am going to correct tags.
-
Comment from azakh-world
Oh, no-no. "public_transport=station" tag would be more suitable, as a "station" is obligatory object at a railway station, and stop_position is optional (or at least less important). Also, "railway=station" tag should be retained since it's still widely used by data consumers.
Yeah, PT is quite complicated theme to not rush to improve it. We support a lot of rapid transit networks around the world, and this validator helps us: http://osm-subway.maps.me
Montreal metro is suffering from loss of its stations :( -
Comment from Alouette955
Same node have been use as stop_position and station. My change have affect station relation and I didn't see it. I have replace railway=station and will verify all station.
-
Comment from azakh-world
Thank you.
Relations (2)
- Métro ligne orange: Côte-Vertu => Montmorency (270251), v29
- Métro ligne orange: Montmorency => Côte-Vertu (3228499), v23
Nodes (1-20 of 25)
- 1
- 2
- Champ-de-Mars (437808230), v11
- Côte-Vertu (437811718), v9
- De La Savane (437811737), v11
- Namur (437811746), v9
- Plamondon (437811771), v13
- Côte-Sainte-Catherine (437811772), v7
- Vendôme (437811839), v8
- Place Saint-Henri (437811884), v12
- Georges-Vanier (437811924), v7
- Bonaventure (437811946), v12
- Square-Victoria-OACI (437811948), v11
- Place d’Armes (437811950), v12
- Sherbrooke (437811969), v9
- Mont-Royal (437811971), v9
- Laurier (437811977), v13
- Rosemont (437811986), v10
- Beaubien (437811988), v8
- Jean-Talon (437811993), v10
- Crémazie (437812003), v9
- Sauvé (437812008), v7
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |