Changeset: 84923472
COGs in Connecticut as no border_type tag, no place tag
Closed by stevea
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (16239 en) |
---|---|
source | US admin_level wiki |
Discussion
-
Comment from Mashin
These are undiscussed and unapproved mass changes. Please revert back to previous state.
-
Comment from stevea
Unless and until there is recent consensus on what it is best to change these boundaries TO, leaving them at a "status quo as agreed to in 2017" seems best. They are not "mass" changes, they are changes to nine relations, and only some modest tagging distinctions (according to our wiki and consensus), none of the actual boundaries were changed. (If many of the boundaries were changed, that might be "mass changes," but it wasn't, so this isn't).
-
Comment from Mashin
Status quo is counties at admin_level=6, as they were for last 10 years. And COGs as admin_level=5 as I originally created those data. If not I will have to escalate this issue.
-
Comment from stevea
When a county has little or no administration, as in Rhode Island (absolutely) and Connecticut (as in "only the judiciary"), then these counties being tagged without a boundary=administrative tag is correct.
EIGHT years ago, I myself suggested that a COG-like thing in California (where I live) might be (I posited it as "might" not "is," as you did) an admin_level=5. It was determined not to be and I and OSM accepted that. You seem bent on not accepting that, yet it is documented to be true.
Escalate away.
-
Comment from Mashin
Even if that would be true, you have no right to change other user’s data. No tags are forbidden even deprecated. And you were not acting from power of DWG.
Relations (9)
- South Central COG (11065394), v4
- Metropolitan COG (11065395), v4
- Western Connecticut COG (11065396), v4
- Northwest Hills COG (11065509), v4
- Naugatuck Valley COG (11065529), v4
- Lower Connecticut River Valley COG (11065862), v4
- Southeastern Connecticut COG (11065863), v4
- Northeastern Connecticut COG (11065864), v4
- Capitol Region COG (11065880), v4
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |