Changeset: 95625069
Sai Kung rural routes
Closed by 小智智
Tags
created_by | JOSM/1.5 (17329 Debian en) |
---|
Discussion
-
Comment from Kovoschiz
Can you explain why would you remove the language tags?
-
Comment from Kovoschiz
`service=` and `passenger=` has been gaining traction in `route=`. I don't see you have any valid reasons to remove them.
-
Comment from Kovoschiz
Not to mention you deleting other's `=stop_position` without any consultation on transitioning to another PT scheme. The combination of `highway=platform` + `public_transport=platform` with `highway=bus_stop` + `public_transport=stop_position` has also been recommended by eg PTv3. A marked bus stop area on the carriageway, or a bus bay, is clearly physical.
-
Comment from Kovoschiz
And not to mention removing `*:wikidata=`, or the full name of the entities.
-
Comment from 小智智
The tags I removed are clearly invalid. service and passenger tags are clearly invalid here as the routes are normal routes (maybe with the exception of 96R). They are general routes serving general passengers. Also owner (a bus route can't be owned) and brand (there is no brand for KMB & LW routes).
Also there is no PTv3. The new proposal does not create a PTv3. stop_position here is redundant and mostly unverifiable (especially in rural areas) so I'm gradually removing them when updating bus routes.
-
Comment from Kovoschiz
1. This is not about "normal routes", but their variety. Have you checked how are they used on trains?
2. I'm talking about language and Wikidata sub-tags.
3. You are arguing about semantics. That's its informal name.
4. How is a stop unverifiable? Are you really saying every one that you removed has no "bus stop" road marking?
5. This is why I'm asking you for. I don't see you discussing this removal, not addition or change in scheme, with anyone else. -
Comment from Kovoschiz
2. * also the full name.
2.1 The bus fleet is owned, no? Same as a rolling stock on trains.
2.2 If you would like to express a common abbreviation, that's what I purport `brand=` for tentatively, which also aligns with the scheme of "MTR Bus", "Light Rail", and others under the MTR mass transit network, operated by MTRCL.
Ways (1-20 of 30)
- 1
- 2
- 883265198, v1
- 大磡道 Tai Hom Road (883265199), v1
- 883265200, v1
- 福民路 Fuk Man Road (883265201), v1
- 北潭路 Pak Tam Road (883265202), v1
- 883265203, v1
- 883265204, v1
- 福民路 Fuk Man Road (883265205), v1
- 883265206, v1
- 883265207, v1
- 26726526, v3
- 26726527, v6
- 大磡道 Tai Hom Road (37669871), v11
- 大磡道 Tai Hom Road (135516502), v6
- 205743809, v8
- 福民路 Fuk Man Road (406708185), v4
- 406708186, v2
- 406708190, v3
- 406897647, v2
- 406897648, v2
Relations (1-20 of 31)
- 1
- 2
- 新界專綫小巴7號線 New Territories Green Minibus 7 (海下 Hoi Ha → 西貢 Sai Kung) (12000855), v1
- 西貢 Sai Kung (12000856), v1
- 新界專綫小巴7號線 New Territories Green Minibus 7 (西貢 Sai Kung → 海下 Hoi Ha) (12000857), v1
- 新界專綫小巴7號線 New Territories Green Minibus 7 (12000858), v1
- 九巴92線 KMB 92 (西貢 Sai Kung → 鑽石山鐵路站 Diamond Hill Railway Station) (1706475), v89
- 九巴92線 KMB 92 (西貢 Sai Kung → 鑽石山鐵路站 Diamond Hill Railway Station (改經新清水灣道 diverted via New Clear Bay Road)) (6455499), v54
- 九巴92線 KMB 92 (西貢 Sai Kung → 彩虹站 Choi Hung Station (特快 Express)) (6455504), v32
- 九巴92線 KMB 92 (6456942), v10
- 九巴92線 KMB 92 (鑽石山鐵路站 Diamond Hill Railway Station → 西貢 Sai Kung (特快 Express)) (6459301), v28
- 九巴92線 KMB 92 (鑽石山鐵路站 Diamond Hill Railway Station → 西貢 Sai Kung) (6459315), v32
- 九巴94線 KMB 94 (西貢 Sai Kung → 黃石碼頭 Wong Shek Pier) (6462856), v13
- 九巴94線 KMB 94 (黃石碼頭 Wong Shek Pier → 西貢 Sai Kung) (6462934), v12
- 九巴94線 KMB 94 (6462935), v4
- 九巴96R線 KMB 96R (鑽石山站 Diamond Hill Station → 黃石碼頭 Wong Shek Pier) (6463073), v34
- 九巴96R線 KMB 96R (黃石碼頭 Wong Shek Pier → 鑽石山站 Diamond Hill Station (特快 Express)) (6463130), v28
- 九巴96R線 KMB 96R (黃石碼頭 Wong Shek Pier → 鑽石山站 Diamond Hill Station) (6463131), v33
- 九巴96R線 KMB 96R (6463132), v7
- 九巴94線 KMB 94 (黃石碼頭 Wong Shek Pier → 西貢 Sai Kung (不停西貢警署 skip Sai Kung Police Station)) (6464474), v9
- 九巴92線 KMB 92 (鑽石山鐵路站 Diamond Hill Railway Station → 西貢 Sai Kung (不停西貢警署 not stopping at Sai Kung Police Station)) (6465171), v26
- 九巴92線 KMB 92 (鑽石山鐵路站 Diamond Hill Railway Station → 西貢 Sai Kung (特快 Express, 不停西貢警署 not stopping at Sai Kung Police Station)) (6465172), v24
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |